Analysis: No. 16 BYU hits rock bottom defensively in 99-92 road loss to unranked Oklahoma State

Analysis: No. 16 BYU hits rock bottom defensively in 99-92 road loss to unranked Oklahoma State

Oklahoma State guard Jaylen Curry (0) shoots the ball over BYU guard Kennard Davis Jr. (30) in the second half of an NCAA college basketball game, Wednesday, Feb. 4, 2026 in Stillwater, Okla.
Oklahoma State guard Jaylen Curry (0) shoots the ball over BYU guard Kennard Davis Jr. (30) in the second half of an NCAA college basketball game, Wednesday, Feb. 4, 2026 in Stillwater, Okla.
|
Mitch Alcala

STILLWATER, Oklahoma — One specific aspect of No. 16 BYU’s 99-92 loss at Oklahoma State Wednesday night seemed to bother Kevin Young the most.

It was the first thing he brought up to reporters postgame, and it was something he came back to reference multiple times thereafter:

Young’s Cougars had no answer for Oklahoma State down low, and the subsequent results proved eye-poppingly jarring.

“Our defense, it was terrible,” Young said bluntly. “They had 52 points in the paint. They scored at will. We couldn’t keep anyone in front of us, and it was just a layup fest. They had 52 points in the paint.”

Those 52 paint points from Oklahoma State — BYU was allowing just over 30 per game entering Wednesday — were the crown jewel of an overall 99-point outburst for the Cowboys, marking the most prolific scoring effort against the Cougars all season and resulting in a court-storming scene at Gallagher-Iba Arena to celebrate the upset victory.

Entering Wednesday, BYU had not lost to an unranked opponent in 22 previous tries dating back to last season. The Cougars had come to Stillwater in search of a bounce back win before heading into a particularly tough Big 12 stretch.

Instead, Young’s team finds itself on a 3-game losing skid and in desperate need of defensive repair at arguably the most difficult point of the schedule to be starting from scratch momentum-wise.

“We’ve just got to get ourselves out of this hole,” BYU’s AJ Dybantsa said after the loss. “KY said in the team meeting after, it’s hard to go through adversity, but I mean, if we want to be the team that we want to be, we’ve got to dig ourselves out this.”

BYU stumbled out the gate, coughing up eight turnovers in the first eight minutes of play to trail by 15 points after nearly 15 minutes.

In all, the Cougars racked up 16 turnovers — 10 coming from Dybantsa and Rob Wright III — which led to 21 Oklahoma State points.

“It was why we got into a hole,” Young said of the turnovers. “AJ was careless with the ball to start, then he started to lock in and that’s when the game changed. I don’t know if we’ve had a game all year where him and Rob had 10 turnovers combined, five apiece.

“You have to credit Oklahoma State, that’s kind of what they do (defensively). However, I thought the (turnovers) we had were actually unforced for the most part, that was the disappointing part.”

Once BYU tightened its ball security, the Cougars caught fire in the half’s final minutes, ending on a 19-4 run to go into halftime with the score tied at 41 points apiece.

But BYU’s brilliant closing stretch of the first half won’t go down as a turning point of the night or the season, but rather just the prelude to an awkward ending.

The Cougars went on to surrender 58 points after halftime in the 7-point loss — though it felt like a much greater margin.

How disappointing was BYU’s defense? Against the Cowboys, the Cougars shot 50% from the field, 43.3% from 3-point range and scored 92 points in a Quad 1, true road environment and still came up short.

As Young would probably point out, giving up 52 paint points goes a long way in erasing such impressive offensive showing.

“I mean, we couldn’t guard the ball. We got too spread out,” Young said. “That’s way too many, you know, 52 points in the paint, it’s not good, right? And then attention to detail, that’s something that our team has struggled with … but more than anything, just our one on one defense was abysmal.”

In all, Oklahoma State averaged 1.32 points per possession, with a sizzling mark of 1.57 PPP in the second half. The Cowboys shot 54.7% from the field, made 22 of 34 free throws, only turned the ball over eight times, and while they only hit seven 3-pointers, five came from Anthony Roy as part of a 30-point performance.

Four other Cowboys players scored in double figures, including Jaylen Curry, whose 18 points off the bench was double the scoring of BYU’s entire reserve unit.

“They play hard, Steve (Lutz) gets his guys ready to really get after you, that’s something I respect about him,” Young said of Oklahoma State. “I don’t know if there was anything that really caught me by surprise, so to speak, but I thought, you know, probably just that (there were so) many guys able to downhill attack, you know, was something that maybe put us on our heels a little bit.

“But, you know, every night in this league is tough, man. It really is. (Tonight) obviously just proved it even more, there’s just no off nights in our league. The talent, the coaching, the atmospheres, it’s top notch.”